One Draft In: Sticking with the Novel That Isn’t Quite Working

By Kaycee Painter

By Joe Massa

At the beginning of this year, I finished the first draft of my novel. The year before, I built up a habit of writing at least 500 words a day, not editing or refining as I went, and ended up with a 170,000 word very, very rough draft. I let all my ideas flow onto the page and I reached the point where it was finally time to stop regularly writing and to start seeing which parts work.

It was uncomfortable switching gears from ideating and drafting without worry, to reading, analyzing, and taking extensive notes on my own writing. I went from my energizing sessions writing absurd, whimsical scenes that future me would know exactly how to stitch together, to being that future me coming face-to-face with my imposter syndrome daily. The deeper I got into this monster of a draft, the more I questioned my own literacy. I would find ways to justify putting off reading the draft while the months slipped by with minimal progress made. 

What made me resist the urge to fully scrap this project and get back on track was that even when I tried to push the project to the side, I found myself thinking about the book. I would be watching a movie and taking notes for a pivot on a character’s arc. I would be falling asleep and realizing that two characters could be one and it would heighten the plot. I kept reading the draft and noticing more things that could work with some twisting. I talked about it with friends, read a bunch of books, did a lot of research, and now, I have a fully annotated ugly first draft, a refreshed outline, and I am ready to set out into my second draft.

I am not here to prescribe you anything to fix your novel. I have in no way cracked the code on writing a book. But if you are someone like me, who works 9 to 5 and manages to find an hour here or there to work on the novel that simply won’t leave your head, here are a few things that helped me keep pushing forward towards the next draft.


Stacking Small Wins

Even during the writing phase of the first draft, it was difficult to get the same output every day I sat down to write. Some days simply aren’t your days. But you can’t look at progress in that way when it comes to a novel-length project. Andrew Sean Greer has a quote about writing a novel where he compares it to doing a crossword puzzle, you let the elements fall into place and inform you as to where they will land in the story. Sometimes that puzzle doesn’t make sense right away, and I accept staring at the screen, walking away, and staring at the screen some more as progress.

In between drafts, progress doesn’t always look like reading and annotating 10 pages of the current draft. Sometimes, I would read a paragraph or two, and then that leads me to a question on whether there is a larger issue within the piece I need to figure out. Then I put on some music or the tv and sit down with my notebook and let my mind decompress through what isn’t working. The next day, I found I was no longer thinking about the issues, but about the parts of the scenes that I enjoyed, the aspects of a character that made me root for them, even the little mistakes that made me giggle enough that maybe they should be intentional the next time around. Not everything was worth rescuing, but I kept turning the page and finding more and more to be excited about within the draft the further I went.


Talking Honestly With Someone You Trust

With this project, I have pushed myself to talk about it with more people than I have ever talked about my writing to. In college, I felt a little embarrassed talking about writing outside of the creative writing classroom. It felt like something I could only bring up in the spaces designated for creative work to live in. But, as I have built my writing life in the real world, and mention that I studied creative writing or like to read and write in my spare time, the more people I have found who write their own poetry, are working on a screenplay, love reading, or have another creative pursuit they want to talk about. Put yourself out there, especially in spaces built to find other people in your writing world, and you never know who you might be your new writing partner. You aren’t going to find them right away, and that’s okay. Every time you talk about your project in a new space, you are speaking it into existence and will get an idea of what the premise feels like to a new audience.

Once you find a sounding board (or boards) for your project, honesty is key. Let them know you are working on a novel and need someone to bounce ideas off. Be vulnerable and tell them what about the project you are struggling with. Those problems are not theirs to fix for you, but if they are a good partner, they will be willing to listen and offer their experience. When it comes time to give them feedback on something, be honest. Put as much effort into giving them feedback as you would want them to give on your own. When they give you feedback, be open to what they are saying. Don’t disregard an idea that doesn’t appeal right away, especially from a trusted source. If anything, ask follow-up questions to try and better understand where they are coming from to diagnose what the actual issue is they are trying to fix. 


Reading and Research

Along with getting to the second draft, another goal of mine throughout this past year was to put a dent in all of the books that stare at me from my bookshelf while I let the next episode of Traitors play. As an undergrad studying creative writing, I was of the mindset that if I am really focused on becoming a better writer, someone who has a unique voice to bring to storytelling, then maybe I am better off not reading anything so that I don’t just mimic the style of the books I like. I could not have been more wrong.

I gravitated back towards reading a few years ago, but I was very casual about it. I was reading maybe a book a month and focusing on whatever was most exciting to me in the moment. Then, after seeing him speak at CityLit Festival, I read Mateo Askaripour’s Black Buck. I loved the writing of the book. It felt very accessible, kept me engaged, and I couldn’t put it down. In the back of the book there is an interview with Askaripour in which he says about the book, “The year I began writing it, 2018, was the year I read the most: sixty books. By reading a variety of books and learning from others about the tradition I was writing in, I came to understand that I am part of something stretching decades into the past.” That quote stuck with me, and I pushed myself to read more, and to read beyond the kinds of books I expected to like.

This year, I have read 25 books so far, which more than doubles the amount I read last year. This includes poetry, a graphic novel, history books, essay collections, short story collections, audiobooks, and many novels. It was incredibly helpful to read these books while keeping my project in mind. Seeing the structures writers take on gave me ideas for how I can organize my sporadic ideas. Seeing how quickly they can move from scene to scene showed me how I can simply move past a scene that wasn’t working and focus on what pulls in the reader the most. Then, when you’ve gotten to the end of a novel and feel like you have gotten everything you could out of it, please go read the acknowledgements. I have found some of the best insights on the writing process within the acknowledgements of a novel I’ve loved. 

One of the most surprising parts of my recent reading journey is learning how much I love nonfiction books. It started with essay collections by Samantha Irby that read like stand-up, but then I needed to up my research for this project. I struggle at times to get through a physical nonfiction book, but I can listen to them as if they were a podcast. If you don’t use Libby to rent audiobooks from the library, I can’t recommend it highly enough. I love nonfiction work where writers turn the lens to analyze themselves and their writing. It’s like a craft book with a history lesson built in. The Message by Ta-Nehisi Coates is one of the best examples of this that I have read. While much of the focus of The Message is on current socio-political issues, Coates frames the whole thing to be a lessen to his students on a willingness to grow with your writing in the face of both criticism and praise. He questions his own writing, faces attempts to ban his books, and travels to do his own research on dangerous assumptions he made in the past. This book shows a writer of the highest pedigree looking inwards to see how he can improve on his previous work, advise the future, and analyze our present moment. 


Listen to The Project, and Trust The Process

A professor in college always said that if you are going to write a book, make sure it is something you want to read because you are going to be reading it constantly. Throughout my first draft, I thought I was writing a concept that I wanted to read, but then I had to read it. I found some parts that could work, but nothing functioned fully as a scene in the way I imagined it would. I was either completely ignoring the setting, resolving the conflict too quickly, or writing each character in my voice so no one stood out. It wasn’t working and I wasn’t excited to work on it.

So, I did all the things. I focused on what was working; I talked through it with friends; I read novels and researched; and then I sat down to write a new outline and I didn’t feel any better about it. At that point, I gave the draft some space. I kept it in the back of my mind but let myself reset while continuing to do some lighter research, like watching movies or YouTube, and working a different side of my brain by drawing. I have always loved drawing and painting, and I have learned a lot about my creative process through it. I know that at the beginning of a project, I want to stop way too early because I get afraid of ruining it or convinced it will never come in to focus. Then, when it is done, my eyes can only go to the spots where my hand slipped, or I pushed the lines a little too dark. When I was younger, I looked out of annoyance that they weren’t perfect. Today, I look at them as a reminder that I am human, my art is human made, and the project wouldn’t be mine without the smudges. Eventually, I made myself keep opening my laptop to at least look at this outline and consider some options as to why I was no longer motivated to write this book. What could motivate me to keep working on this project I have already spent over a year developing?

Finally, I realized I didn’t understand what my characters were motivated by. I had all these fun ideas on things that each of them would do, but I had no idea why they were doing them. So, I found the time to sit down and write out mini arcs for each of my characters, basing their motivations around the scenes I was most eager to write. Some came naturally; others I had to work a little harder at. But I just leaned towards making the decision that would make me most excited to write it. Even if they felt a little bold or wonky, those decisions are where readers will get to see that me, a human, wrote this book.


If you take anything from this, it’s to be willing to serve yourself with your novel. Write what makes your ears perk up, and even if it isn’t working yet, you will have the energy to figure out why. By the end of my analysis of the rough draft and development of a detailed outline for my second draft, I had scrapped a large portion of the first draft, combined characters into one, and added a whole b and c-plot that weren’t a part of the original. Now, I’m starting to build back up to my daily writing practice and struggling a bit to switch back into that gear. But, nonetheless, I am still thinking about the book every day, excited to read the next draft and hate it all over again.

Leave a Reply